Cryptocurrency exchange operators—including Coinbase, Kraken, and Circle—have collaborated to establish a scoring system that rates digital tokens based on their resemblance to securities under U.S. regulations.
The Cryptocurrency Rating Council Framework
Coinbase unveiled the rating system in a blog post, developed by the newly formed Cryptocurrency Rating Council (CRC). The framework evaluates digital assets using a 1-to-5 scale, where:
- 1: Minimal or no security-like characteristics (e.g., Bitcoin).
- 5: Strong resemblance to traditional securities (e.g., certain ICO tokens).
The system leverages SEC guidelines to assess compliance with U.S. securities laws, providing exchanges with clarity on whether to support specific assets.
Key Objectives
- Standardize Compliance: Help exchanges navigate regulatory ambiguity.
- Increase Adoption: Enable financial services firms to expand cryptocurrency offerings confidently.
- Transparency: Publish ratings to inform market participants.
Founding Members
The CRC’s founding members include:
- Coinbase
- Kraken
- Circle
- Anchorage
- Bittrex
- Genesis Trading
- Grayscale Investments
👉 Explore how top exchanges are shaping crypto regulations
Implications for Major Cryptocurrencies
- Bitcoin (BTC) & Litecoin (LTC): Rated 1 (least likely to be classified as securities).
- XRP: Rated closer to 5, conflicting with Ripple CEO’s public stance that XRP is not a security.
This aligns with SEC Chair Jay Clayton’s past statements:
"Bitcoin is not a security, but ICO tokens are."
Industry Impact
The CRC addresses long-standing uncertainty about whether cryptocurrencies qualify as securities—a debate that escalated during the 2017 ICO boom, where many investors suffered losses.
FAQ Section
Q: Why does the rating matter?
A: It influences whether exchanges list a token and how regulators might treat it.
Q: Can ratings change?
Yes. Coinbase noted ratings may evolve as issuers provide additional context or regulations shift.
Q: How does this affect XRP?
A: A higher rating could subject it to stricter compliance, potentially impacting its liquidity.
Looking Ahead
The CRC plans to refine its methodology and engage with token issuers for feedback. As Coinbase stated:
"We expect ratings to adapt over time."
👉 Stay updated on crypto regulatory developments