Bitcoin Cash (BCH) was introduced on August 1, 2017, as a fork of Bitcoin (BTC). Its primary goal was to increase the block size limit, enabling faster and cheaper transactions while rejecting Segregated Witness (SegWit), a Bitcoin protocol upgrade implemented around the same time.
Initially, BCH gained little attention, but its popularity surged after it publicly opposed the "New York Agreement" and proceeded with a hard fork to expand Bitcoin’s block size.
On November 8, 2017, after six key executives abandoned the SegWit2x hard fork proposal, BCH’s price skyrocketed from 0.08333 BTC to an all-time high of 0.24613 BTC. This surge attracted significant media attention, particularly from CNBC.
However, BCH has since plummeted 87.5% against BTC and 91% in USD value compared to its 2017 peak. Despite occasional rumors of a "BCH comeback," key network metrics continue to decline, especially when compared to Bitcoin.
Here are three major reasons why Bitcoin Cash has struggled to regain its momentum.
1. Bitcoin’s Dominance as a Store of Value
The primary reason for BCH’s underperformance lies in Bitcoin’s dominance as a digital store of value. According to Chainalysis, 90% of Bitcoin’s network activity is tied to exchanges, highlighting its role as an investment asset rather than a payment method.
Key Insights:
- High Transaction Fees ≠ Dealbreaker – BTC users prioritize security and decentralization over low fees.
- Market Demand Favors BTC – Investors prefer Bitcoin’s scarcity (21M supply cap) over BCH’s focus on cheap transactions.
- Network Effects Reinforce BTC’s Position – Bitcoin’s first-mover advantage and liquidity make it difficult for BCH to compete.
👉 Learn why Bitcoin remains the crypto market leader
2. Bitcoin’s Unmatched Network Effects
BTC’s network effects—liquidity, hash power, and brand recognition—create formidable barriers for competitors like BCH.
Comparing BTC vs. BCH:
| Metric | Bitcoin (BTC) | Bitcoin Cash (BCH) |
|----------------------|--------------|-------------------|
| 24-Hr Trading Volume | $4.5B+ | $187M |
| Hash Rate Share | ~97.3% | ~2.7% |
| Median Fee | $0.70 | <$0.01 |
Why This Matters:
- Security Concerns – BCH’s low hash rate makes it vulnerable to 51% attacks.
- Liquidity Gap – Traders favor BTC due to deeper markets and higher adoption.
- Brand Strength – Institutions and retail investors overwhelmingly prefer Bitcoin.
3. Competition from Altcoins & Bitcoin Layer-2 Solutions
BCH faces fierce competition from:
- Litecoin (LTC) – Adopted SegWit and Lightning Network earlier than BTC.
- Ethereum (ETH) – Shifted focus to DeFi, offering better utility than BCH.
- Bitcoin Layer-2s – Lightning Network enables fast, low-cost BTC transactions.
Emerging BTC Innovations:
- Schnorr/Taproot – Improves privacy and scalability.
- Drivechains & Sidechains – Projects like Liquid and RSK enhance functionality without hard forks.
👉 Discover how Bitcoin’s Layer-2 solutions work
FAQ: Bitcoin Cash (BCH) vs. Bitcoin (BTC)
Q1: Will BCH ever surpass its 2017 all-time high?
A: Unlikely. BTC’s dominance, network effects, and investor preference for scarcity make a BCH resurgence improbable.
Q2: Why does BCH have lower fees than BTC?
A: Larger blocks allow more transactions per block, but this comes at the cost of centralization and weaker security.
Q3: Is BCH a good investment compared to BTC?
A: Bitcoin remains the preferred choice for long-term holders due to its liquidity, security, and institutional adoption.
Conclusion
Bitcoin Cash’s struggle stems from:
- BTC’s superior store-of-value appeal.
- Network effects that reinforce Bitcoin’s dominance.
- Competition from altcoins and Bitcoin’s own scaling solutions.
While BCH aimed to improve transaction efficiency, market demand has consistently favored Bitcoin’s security and scarcity. For those seeking low fees, Ethereum and Bitcoin’s Lightning Network offer more viable alternatives.
Final Verdict: BCH’s challenges highlight why Bitcoin remains the dominant cryptocurrency.